@Captain24 hiya! Hehe heck yes, garlic bread!
Okay so, that feeling of 'impostor syndrome' is not at all uncommon for many queer folks who don't quite fit into more 'mainstream' (for lack of a better word) identities. I reckon it's mainly to do with the fact that sexuality and romantic attraction are such individual, fluid, and complex experiences. Humans love a label because it helps us to identify common ground that we might share - however, most of us don't fit perfectly into one label or another. So, often people who don't fully fit into one category or another end up feeling like impostors, or like they're straddling two communities.
Another complication to this is that people can experience romantic attraction separately to physical attraction - which is why both asexual and aromantic identities exist. Some folks also experience split attraction, where they may want romantic connections without the sex, or sexual connections without romance. Or they might feel romantically attracted to women, but sexually attracted to men.
And yet more complexity - the identity that most strongly fits my experiences is 'demisexual' - some put it under the banner of asexuality, some consider it a separate identity altogether - but basically it describes exactly what you said above: I don't experience sexual attraction to like... anyone until I have formed an emotional connection with them. This is why I strongly related to asexuality for ages, cos up till I met my previous partners, the idea of wanting to have sex with someone before even talking to them was just ludicrous to me.
Humans may love a binary, but nature... she don't really do binaries 😉
So when you said,
@Captain24 wrote:
I’d have to build a deep connection first. Gender is no issue for me either. If I connect with someone then it doesn’t matter to me who they are.
I was just sat here like 'Oh lookie we probably have the same or similar queer identities! Cos this is SO ME!' 😋
I consider myself demi-pansexual; pansexuality basically means being attracted to 'multiple genders' (i.e. like what you said, that gender is no real issue) - maybe that suits you too?
As with anything in queer-world, no one gets to decide what identity makes the most sense for us, and no one gets to police whether or not we belong to the queer community. You're as much a part of it as I am - if you want to be!