FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Our stories

Weird Moral Dilemma....

Weird Moral Dilemma....

Hi Everyone,

There's something I have wanted to share with others on SANE for a few days now.

Tomorrow I am going to the big city to see my "best friend". I haven't seen her for months. She is a difficult woman but I care about her very much. We have know each other for 20 years.

She can be extremely fun-loving and entertaining and often has amazing insights in other people's behavior, and hence we have some great, therapeutic discussions. She has a very good heart and a strong moral compass. We actually understand each other very well.

However (there had to be a catch), she can also be extremely judgemental and critical. This results in her making some hurtful, dismissive comments that really sting. Her other close friends totally agree with me on this. They have both experienced her dark side. One friend just accepts it and tries to ignore it as much as she can. The other friend has kept her distance at times, because she is sensitive to the criticisms and has been hurt by them.

So...... just last week my husband and I bought a house! The thing is, and this is going to sound so petty- our new house is bigger than my best friend's house. Not only that, but we are now mortgage free, whereas she is not.... sadly this is partly due to her divorce settlement. A very sore point with her.

I know through past experience, my friend will spend 5 minutes congratulating me on our new house and then at least half an hour interrogating me about our finances and our intentions in the future.... throwing in a few negative comments about the house, etc, etc. This is what she does. Her behavior tends to make me feel very anxious! It's a terrible feeling.

I think my friend behaves like this because she is insecure. I am insecure too, so her behavior really plays on me. I believe she is not really aware of how she comes across to others. This is one area where she has no insight.

So: I am actually thinking of not telling her that we bought a house. That way I can enjoy the weekend, not have to worry about being criticised (the criticism only happens when something good occurs in my life) and tell her some other time when we have less time to spend together.

Do people out there think this is particularly dishonest? How much do you share with friends and how much to they expect you to share?

I haven't told very many people about the house at all. I am private by nature.

38 replies

31 - 38 of 38
1...34

In response to: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Thanks @Former-Member and @Silenus,

OTE, yes it might seem a bit confusing. I doubt I have overcome the issue in the long run. I still get a lot anxiety around friendships and also with this one woman in particular because her relationship style is so confrontational.

There was one incident where I mentioned that I wanted to do my doctorate in art at uni, perhaps even starting this year. I felt my friend was initially excited for me, but then picked apart my reasons for wanting to do it, and told me that it was going to be really hard for me to get a place at uni! As if she would know!! She is not in university administration and has not done her post graduate studies. There was no need for her to tell me I was going to have a hard time getting into uni!

Of course, I had to side-step around her comments, and keep the conversation light. I guess this is just her style, she does not at all feel that she is being too confrontational or critical. But I think that yes, at that monent in time, I did start to get anxious and started to put walls up and try to change the subject and everything.

I suppose, again, the real problem is my anxiety. I mean, everyone has a "dark side" and the closer we get to that person, the more we are going to end up seeing it. Also, if you go out into the world, you will have to deal with the 'dark sides' of other people you meet who are not even your friends, but people you have no choice but to deal with.... for example, at work.

I suppose I am still working out how much I want to deal with people who upset me and how much work I still have to do on myself.

thanks so much, guys!

In response to: Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

I am just thinking further into the future. I am thinking that it could be a good idea to have some challenging people in my life, so as that I am forced to grow. My critical friend would certainly be great for that!

The good thing is that I don't see her all the time. I'm sure that if she lived in the house next to me, then I would end up trying to avoid her as much as possible, becuase I don't need to be challenged constantly.

I suppose that with the difficult people in your life, you end up learning to manage them. Whether that takes the form of with-holding certain information, changing the subject of conversation, distracing them and deflecting attention from yourself or whatever. If you only have to do these things occasionally and they don't cause you much stress, then the friendship can endure.

If, however, you were constantly on guard, forever trying to say the correct thing and feeling super anxious, then it wouldn't be worth it.

In response to: Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

just got posted twice!

In response to: Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....


@Sahara wrote:

Thanks @Former-Member and @Silenus,

OTE, yes it might seem a bit confusing. I doubt I have overcome the issue in the long run. I still get a lot anxiety around friendships and also with this one woman in particular because her relationship style is so confrontational.

There was one incident where I mentioned that I wanted to do my doctorate in art at uni, perhaps even starting this year. I felt my friend was initially excited for me, but then picked apart my reasons for wanting to do it,

I did start to get anxious and started to put walls up and try to change the subject and everything.

I suppose, again, the real problem is my anxiety. I mean, everyone has a "dark side" and the closer we get to that person, the more we are going to end up seeing it. Also, if you go out into the world, you will have to deal with the 'dark sides' of other people you meet who are not even your friends, but people you have no choice but to deal with.... for example, at work.

thanks so much, guys!


Hi Sahara,

I just wrote a long thoughtful reply and lost it - grrr. Will try again.

I think I understand what you are saying - that your anxiety is the problem in this friendship (your fear of confrontation) and that you need challenging people in your life to learn to deal with it. To be stronger and learn to flick it off to enjoy their company more fully and not be effected by their personality flaws. You are saying that will make you less anxious.

In part yes anxiety is the problem, (the other part is her bad behaviour) - this is true because anxiety/fear can sometimes weaken our natural defences to stand up for ourselves protecting our minds/self esteem when nessecary. If we allow it anxiety can lower our confidence to not assert our true value in relationships by being passive when we should act - asking politely for respect. The more we allow people to upset us regardless how small, big, frequent or infrequent the attacks are (constant criticism in your case) because of anxiety (fear of confrontation) - the worse it will get. No doubt that is a weakness we need to work on for our own good.

Anxiety will try and tell as that there "is no problem with the person or their behaviour or "that they are getting better/improving while still putting us down; trying in our minds to minimise the damage or harm incurred" so we don't have to challenge our own fears or the relationship. That's how fear works - avoidance. Some hide from life because of their anxieties. And nothing gets resolved so the anxiety keeps increasing. That's when anxiety can become a mental prison. Much more beneficial in the long run to face it and the problem at hand.

In my life experience no-one will come out of being putting down on a "continual basis" every time they see certain individuals unscathed or uneffected if they don't speak up or stand up for themselves Sahara. Your other friends who do so know this and are dealing effectively with your friend. If she chooses to continue to act this like this towards them then they will move away for their own well being. Yes, working on the problem of anxiety by speaking up when something is wrong is good - that is not happening when we minimise the ill effect your friend or others have on you and side stepping it (that's avoidance). Your feelings are important as is your mental health - and relationships are a two way street (respect goes both ways).

Even though it's not on a regular basis that you see this person as yes ofcourse that would be more damaging - it still leaves it's mental mark and frustrations that can boil over as you have expressed here. That increases anxiety and not good for those who are vulnerable to such. If there wasn't a problem with your relationship with this lady - if it was only your anxiety as the problem - you wouldn't be posting here. I hear you. Always stick up for yourself.

In my experience engaging with challenging or difficult people either in friendships/workmates/partners and just side stepping their attacks/put downs won't strengthen the mind or ease anxiety to deal with the outside world - on the contrary, it will weaken the mind by increasing anxiety as our self esteem/confidence lowers making us less able to deal with outside challenges and difficult people. Choosing to be around positive people enhances worth thus mental health which helps to ease anxiety. I choose to surround myself as much as possible with them to promote sound mental growth and inner healing.

But when there is no choice such as in the workforce or difficult family members etc, I stand up for myself if continually criticised, put down and disrespected. That's what you do with bullies. And being continually criticised is a form of bullying - accepting that as human flaws does not make it okay in my book.

Ofcourse there are situations where we make make allowances for "harmless human flaws or for a bad day" as no one is perfect, but that's not to say we don't politely comment "that was cutting"; - but if put downs/rudeness/disrespect/criticisms are happening "continually" then that is crossing the line and if accepted will only get worse. If we continue to allow this it empowers the other persons bad behaviour, harms us and does no one any favours. (I.e. DV situations start off with putting up with disrespect and put downs as it is condoning the behaviour). There has to be a line drawn in the sand that others can't cross. Vital in friendships/relationships or they become toxic in my humble opinion.

You speak of others dark side - as something we need to learn to accept and deal with because everyone has one including ourselves (except warts and all). No way. Not healthy to accept that in ourselves or others as okay in my opinion (learnt the hard way). Unfortunately I have had exposure of people's dark sides too often in the past (DV, childhood/adult abuse, manipulation, sexual abuse, bodily harm, and deliberate attacks on my mind (continual put downs). Not something I like to speak of or will again. It's dark/negative. I do so to point out that there is a "big differentiation" between "human flaws/imperfections and a dark side".

A dark side is defined by sociopathic/narcissistic/psychopathic traits whose intentions purposefully seek their self empowerment and indulgence over the welfare of individuals who cross their paths; and whom remain unremorseful of their actions, remain indifferent to the damage/harm incurred by others by the deliberate "choices" they make; even after being enlightened they are hurting another (full knowledge of what they are doing). On what scale that dark side is on depends on how far the individual is prepared to go to get their way or how much they release their vices/negative emotions on others to bring them down in order to self empower - and they thrive on it because they are weak individuals; and the scale of their dark side is dependant on how much of their humanity they have lost. The more they act on their negative traits the more of a monster they become.

Human flaws/imperfections are different - they are defects of personality that can annoy, offend or have a detrimental/negative effect on others that the individual is "not fully aware they are doing". Or not fully aware to the extent of harm it is producing. "They don't intend harm". Usually when enlightened to the harm their human imperfections are creating - people feel remorseful they are hurting others and damaging their quality of relationships and will be genuinely sorry reflected "by working on their flaws for better change" - as this exhibits the value they place on the other.

If change of their flaws isn't happening even if they say they are sorry but getting worse - they are not genuinely remorseful - they aren't valuing/respecting the people or themselves enough to do so (that is what's toxic). That is the big difference - and how we can discern what human imperfections are versus a dark side (judges/lawyer have this moral dilemma a lot when sentencing).

And so no, not everyone has a dark side - all can have some degree of human imperfection on different scales depending on their awareness of it and how hard they work on them. These flaws don't always grow to the extension of a full blown dark side. As once a person is there it is difficult to come back as they continue to justify their actions with no remorse seeing no wrong - they make up their own laws of morality as they go along that suits their agenda or twisted thinking; blind to what they are becoming and that is where true psychopathic madness can entrench; that is the reality of endless darkness. Most of us are not like that thank goodness.

If remorse is truely present (only the case if they are proactively improving - working on their behaviour creating change) or not (having no remorse by continuing to "choose" to behaviour in a matter that hurts others continually once they are made aware). That's how we discern a dark side - the latter. It's wise to move away from such individuals as harm will inevitably occur.

If they aren't sorry and don't change - their behaviour can worsen and develop into "a personality disorder". Mental illness can result from such - not always the other way around. And those of us who have been mentally ill with perception distorted still know they are doing wrong if told repeatedly or by learning from our mistakes ; mental illness does not take that ability to make choices (this forum is evident of that) - not making others responsible does (making excuses continually for them).

The onus is therefore not on those in relationships with them (such as yourself in this instance), - the onus is on the indivual who is offending to help themselves and the only way they can do this is by taking full responsibility of their actions by addressing that "they have a problem". Or nothing changes. Your part is to not allow your anxiety to stop you from sticking up for yourself.

I have had more life experience in this area (starting with myself) than I would care to acknowledge.

When I was at my lowest anxiety/depression wise I surrounded myself with positive people for healing. Then did I become strong enough to take on the more challenging tasks, life events and people if necessary (in my work). And by standing up for myself if continually attacked and disrespected - whether in the home, occasionally or at work was absolutely nessecary to not decline back into becoming once again anxious and depressed.

I can see my younger self in you Sahara and like me I think you are growing more within and are looking for something better - more genuine, fulfilling relationships with kind, positive loving others whom "you can be yourself with warts and all" and not fear being put down. It goes both ways. Whom will be genuinely happy and supportive of you. Even though these type of relationships can take time to nurture as trust needs to be earned, and the fact people are busier in their lives more - they are out there and you will find them. Don't give up or settle for less because of loneliness as this will pass. That's my insight on this Sahara and will leave it there for you to take what is helpful in your situation. It's up to you. Sending all my love to you

In response to: Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....


@OverTheEdge wrote:

Of course there are situations where we make make allowances for "harmless human flaws or for a bad day" as no one is perfect, but that's not to say we don't politely comment "that was cutting"; - but if put downs/rudeness/disrespect/criticisms are happening "continually" then that is crossing the line and if accepted will only get worse. If we continue to allow this it empowers the other persons bad behaviour, harms us and does no one any favours. (I.e. DV situations start off with putting up with disrespect and put downs). Should someone accept a partner like that warts and all - ofcourse not. There has to be a line drawn in the sand that others can't cross. Same in friendships or they become toxic in my humble opinion.

Hi @Former-Member,

thanks so much for taking the time to write. It means a lot to me that you care enough to write such an in-depth reply. Yes, my friend does 'cross the line' in my opinion. I wondered myself if continued exposure to her cutting behavior might not be detrimental to my mental health.

It's a bit of a problem that I have had for some years now. So much has changed in those few years and I have, at times, explained to my friend that I find her criticisms cross the line. When I do complain, she apologises - but then the behavior continues. Which goes to show it must be a deeply ingrained psychological problem that she may never be able to address.

In the time we spent together, there were other things that also made me feel that she is not a happy person and that she has a lot of work to do. They were just small things, but they were there.

One of the things was her conspicuous spending on jewelery that she doesn't need. (Ok, no-one needs jewelery, do they?) This time, she even said she has some regrets about buying the jewelery. She has never mentioned having regrets before, so this was something new. Maybe there was some self-awareness there in my friend?

Another thing was that when we went out to a bar, she actually looked uncomfortable and rarely smiled. This is after repeatedly saying "I just want to go out and have some fun." Well, for someone who wants to have fun - she didn't seem to try all that hard. There was nothing wrong with the bar; it had live music, dim lighting and a crowd of well-behaved people who were around our age. It was an ideal bar, but my friend looked uncomfortable.

Another thing was that she said she got completely drunk a few weeks ago with friends (not something to be hugely proud of, but we've all done it! ) and she ended up swearing, being verbally confrontational and making a spectacle of herself. Interesting that she mentioned her behaviour to me, considering that it wasn't exactly socially acceptable behaviour! Again, I wonder if there is some new self-awareness there in my friend?

All this just points to the fact that I need to be very aware and proceed with caution in the friendship. She may very well be a toxic person or at least heading that way. The thing is that I have known her for 20 years and I still can't quite make up my mind about it!

In response to: Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Hi my pleasure @Sahara, You will work it out in time my friend - what is good for you and what is not to avoid. All comes in time and reflection. x

In response to: Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Hi @Former-Member @Sahara

Hi @Former-Member

I cannot believe how cool your image is. I need to read up here on these groovy posts.

Who is the one who wants to do a doctorate in art ??

My dream too but my dream is also going a different direction these days. Also, it might be coming more to a reality....well, I'm putting down things now I've completely cut contact with my Mum. She has been a terrible person in my life all my life but after the car accident over 30 years ago, her dissappearing from my life for 20 years and me having to manage it for the past 10 years...I can't do it anymore and I've blocked her out of my life.

On toxic people. Yes, I've put my hand up on trying to see people from the other side but....my brother the one who is cut out of the family is the person who is giving me strength. He keeps on writing to me; Just take care of yourself PP.

..I have made so many mistakes......

But something made me see a Psychotherapist since I was 24 years old. I am 48 now.

In response to: Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Re: Weird Moral Dilemma....

Hi @PeppiPatty,

I'm sorry to hear about your relationahip with your Mum. I had a very difficult relationship with my Mum, too. I suppose you could describe my Mum as a toxic person, but I believe she had an MI that went undignosed her whole life. She was very high functioning. My Dad always enabled her to get away with everything.

Anyway, she sadly passed away last year from a very long illness.

I am a similar age to you, @PeppiPatty. I am 46. I first sought professional help for depression 11 years ago. I probably left it too long to seek help. I first started seeking panic attacks at 8 years of age.

If you would like to go ahead and study your doctorate in art then start making steps towards it. I don't think you will regret it.

All the best to you!

31 - 38 of 38
1...34