FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Something’s not right

Why care about suiciders?

Why care about suiciders?

Hi, don't get something. Why do people care about others dying or suiciding? If someone suicides, surely we should be relieved for them. I don't want others to worry or be upset if I die...heck, throw a party in my honour and make sure no one leaves sober! I'll be free and happy. I get family and close friends feeling upset...although I wish they would be happy for me. I know it's selfish for someone to suicide but it's selfish to keep someone alive when they are damaged beyond healing. I should say, I don't feel anything at the moment so maybe that is the reason this is a bad question...I hope I am not upsetting people. Why do people care about others? It's so illogical.

46 replies

41 - 46 of 46
1...45

In response to: Why care about suiciders?

Re: Why care about suiciders?

I'm referring to acceptance comittment therapy @Lemonjuice. It's worth checking out when you have time. Click here for a brief intro. I see it as a sort of bridge between CBT and mindfulness because it draws on principles of both.

In response to: Why care about suiciders?

Re: Why care about suiciders?

@Former-Member Thanks for that. I have heard of it. I don't doubt it's usefulness, however, I think a marriage is long overdue between the 'here and now' practices with the depth psychologies. I think we do need to know our past traumas because they have not been emtionally processed, however, it is equally important to practice getting on in life in the present. For example, take someone was traumatized through sexual abuse as a child and now fears new relationships. Some might have only partial memory of the event, their sexual maturity may be stunted, their emotions unprocessed. Working with someone just treating their present anxiety might get them to a date but the energy of unprocessed info and emotions will just show up later in other ways, ie, sex...It's kicking the can down the road. On the other side, just working with the past ad nauseam doesn't allow for present day reality testing. So to my mind both are needed and to my knowledge, there is little in the way of working with both sides. Either you provide CBT treatments or depth type treatments, it's rare to find someone providing both.

How's the college program btw? I have thought about training with them. Is it fairly eclectic or strictly cbt?

In response to: Why care about suiciders?

Re: Why care about suiciders?

@Lemonjuice

iv just seen this thread and i think the same as you. this is a great thread. i havent read all of the comment yet but i will do when i have time.

In response to: Re: Why care about suiciders?

Re: Why care about suiciders?

Hi @Lemonjuice

I like what you say about the "then" and "now" _ I think - we need to feel free to talk about the past and how far we have come and how different things are now

I had something happen this week - I was discussing my medication with my GPs partner and at the time I had enough pain to screech but suppressed that and I do hate having a discussion about my medication and my pain specialist has the attitude and wrote to my GP - It's not his intention to change anything when the client is stable"

I mentioned a drug I refused to take in the past and the GP wanted to know why - and for that moment I really couldn't think of the answer rather than I didn't trust it - but she looked up what my pain specialist had written at the time - that she didn't think a change in medication was to be considered when I was so unstable

I had to think about that because I had forgotten - this was just after my mother died and I was all over the place but suicide was not on my mine but I remembered that after my son died I had thoughts - I doubts - it was not even suicidal ideation - over 30 years ago - but I was a mess and not thinking clearly but still - that was a long time ago and my pain specialist took that seriously after my mother died a few years ago - and wow - why should that come back and smack me in the face this week when I have had so much other unrelated stuff and some of it heavy this week.

So we all have a past and that past is part of whom we are now - and an event years ago can flick into our face at the wrong time and it can cause a moment of distraction and misunderstandings can occur

I don't think I was in any way in any danger of suicide over thirty years ago and certainly not 3 years ago but this convo has made me think -

Then was a then and this is a now and things change but it is all part of our story and who we are now

Thanks for that

Dec

In response to: Why care about suiciders?

Re: Why care about suiciders?

@Owlunar Sometimes the past can reach out of the past and just grab you. When you're actually going through the event, you push things aside to deal with things...there's no time to think about emotions or feeling overwhelmed enough to think about suicide. But weeks, months, years later, when the crisis is past, all the thoughts (even the 'I wish I was here' or suicidal thoughts) and feelings you wouldn't allow yourself to think come through. It will calm down with time.

In response to: Re: Why care about suiciders?

Re: Why care about suiciders?

Thanks @Lemonjuice

I am not suicidal in any way now - and my son killed himself over 30 years ago and I did feel as if it was all too much then and that passed - but when my mother died a lot came back and suicide was not even remotely in my thoughts but the medication suggested at the time had warnings - including the risk of suicide and that stopped me from taking them and I really did think about the past then

This week though - my therapist - I am seeing her for family issues - is helping me to really focus on the situation through life between my mother and my sister, and me - through a long life time of intolerance and real bad behaviour from them and I wonder I got through this in one piece and think I must be a pretty tough cookie

But uh uh - no - I was often really fragile and I remember taking the thoughts of suicide of the table - how could I do that to my daughter? - she had already lost her brother to suicide - that was enough - and so - no - no way could I do that

Take suicide and any possibily of it off the table and a fragile and emotional person can only go one way and that is up and out but I acknowledge that is is a terrible way to live - battling every day for as long as it took to live with the loss of my son and the heartless and thoughtless comments of my mother and sister and I would just take myself away from them and their bitchy behaviour -

Okay - yeah - the pain came up like an explosion from deep in the past when my mother died - the memories - ah no - I just had to tell my therapist this - and my GPs partner wants to question my medication this week - no - I hate this - what is the alternative - a lifetime in severe pain - yikes - people talk about "weening myself off" and have no answer to what then - my spine is worse than it was and nothing has or can be done to fix it - how can the medication cause the pain when it was there in the beginning?

So you are right - suicide is not an alternative either - living my life is - but a lot as come back in the last few days and I do not need extra - I do not

And I have every confidence that many other people - whatever their issues - have had that - no one needs extra - no one does

Thanks Lemonjuice

Dec

41 - 46 of 46
1...45