FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Recovery Club

Justice system is not just

Justice system is not just

F**k life!

I've posted here a lot about my struggles about getting out of an emotionally abusive relationship. Well, the justice system - which one would thing would at least attempt to be fair - has screwed me too.

I left my psychologically abusive partner 6 months ago, on the pressing of a trauma psychologist. For the record, we are not married, have no children, shared housework evenly, and are on just about the same incomes (actually, she earns a tiny bit more than me, but whatever).

Since then, I have been couch surfing. I've still paid my share of the mortgage and bills because that's what I signed up for and I feel obligated to honour that. However, that has meant I have not been able to afford to rent anywhere else.

After talking to my ex-partner a number of times, I made her an offer to buy her share out of our house. I did due diligence and contacted 4 real estate agents who gave me an appraisal of what they thought the property was now worth. I worked out the average of these appraisals. I downloaded all our bank statements since the purchase of the property and added up who contributed what. It turns out, on average, I contributed about 60% more to the mortgage repayments and running costs of the house (bills, rates, groceries, etc).

I also discovered that she had ceased contributing to the mortgage and bills months ago. She had in effect been living in our house for "free" whilst I was essentially homeless.

However, to encourage action and make my offer more palatable to her I offered to put her out at 60%. She would get 20% from the sale of the property than she put in.

Well, she rejected this offer, and demanded 80% instead. At this point I contacted a few lawyers. I thought "Surely they can provide a clear letter to her with the bank statements showing that I was entitled to 60% of the property. Surely this will make her reasonably accept my original offer". Nope. Both lawyers I talked to said that, in a relationship, all assets, including your savings, the value of your car, even your f**king super, are pooled together and distributed evenly. Further more, they both said the cost of going through mediation, then court, as well as the costs of the lawyers them selves would be greater than what I would lose if I paid her the 80%. They also said this could potentially drag on for years, all the while my ex can legally not pay mortgage, because the contract includes us both.

So, I caved. I offered her the 80%. She would get back twice the amount she paid into the mortgage. She would get twice the amount she is owed from the increase in value of the property. And, she gets to continue living there for free whilst I still pay her cost.

How is this just? How is this even close to fair?

This. This is why I hate living. I HATE it so much.

19 replies

11 - 19 of 19

In response to: Justice system is not just

Re: Justice system is not just

No worries @tyme

"What does support look like to you? Do you prefer people to share their experiences, share resources that may be helpful, people to just check-in a say hi to you?"

I don't know.

All I know is I need some kind of support but there doesnt seem to be anything out there that helps.

In response to: Re: Justice system is not just

Re: Justice system is not just

Hahaha, knew there would be a "living fee". It costs money to even lodge a bloody property consent form.

So, my ex-partner wants to take all my money. My lawyer wants to take all my money. The court system wants to take all my money.

Hell, let me open it up!

Anyone here want some of my money? It's going to get syphoned off anyway, so may as well go to people who actually need it.

In response to: Re: Justice system is not just

Re: Justice system is not just

Hi @Jlol, I am so sorry to hear what's been happening. I just caught up with your posts and can't imagine how stressful this must be. It is incredibly unfair what's happening. 😞

I can hear that you're frustrated, and rightly so - anyone in your situation would have been.

I am here to chat - I know it won't fix anything but I just hope you know that you have someone to talk to about what's going on

In response to: Re: Justice system is not just

Re: Justice system is not just

Thanks @lavenderhaze,

To be honest with you I'm worried I'm not going to make it.The stress is just too much.

Not having somewhere to live, being gaslit and manipulated by my ex, the complete lack of support, ther purposeful obfuscation of information, and the endless, endless, endless fees. All the while going to work with a smile on my face because if I don't I will not be able to pay these endless fees.

I can't trust any lawyers because each one I've spoken to has said different, conflicting things and every time I ask even a simple question it costs hundreds of dollars. I've spent days compiling spreadsheets for our finances, documenting all our expenses and communications on the bequest of these lawyers but they don't even look at them.

I've called legal help lines but all they're good for are clarifying terminology. Of course they cannot comment on particular cases.

It sickens me that to get justice - even for a very cut and dry case - you need to pay lawyers. The ones I have now are $550/hour! It wasn't long ago I was earn $8/hr. So, basically, the person with the biggest wallet wins. And since my ex has refused to pay her share of the bills and mortgage for 5 months, she has a pretty damn big wallet right now.

TW: SI, edited by moderator

Content/trigger warning
Honestly, this has been so stressful that I've been having suicidal thoughts as a result.

But the stupid/funny part is I can't even talk to anyone about the "s" word because in QLD they lock you up for it. The whole duty of care thing in QLD is so dumb it's even funny.

It seems so straight forward to me: We have no kids, have the same paying jobs, I paid 60% of the costs of the house. She can buy me out at 60% the appraised value, I buy her out at 40% the appraised value, or we sell and get a 60/40 split. Yet the system will not allow it.

In response to: Re: Justice system is not just

Re: Justice system is not just

I am so sorry @Jlol, I can imagine how emotionally and financially challenging this must be. I will send you an email, please look out for it 💜

In response to: Re: Justice system is not just

Re: Justice system is not just

I wonder if the forum operators recognise the irony of censoring my mentioning of the "s" word in the same paragraph where I talk about how you're openly discouraged about talking about the "s" word.

In response to: Re: Justice system is not just

Re: Justice system is not just

Hi @Jlol - we don't discourage discussion about suicide, however we do want to ensure that the forums are a safe space for everyone. This means that members can discuss suicide, but we ask that they're mindful of how the discussion may be impactful for others who are struggling with suicide ideation. You can read more about the way to talk about suicide safely in a public forum here.

In response to: Re: Justice system is not just

Re: Justice system is not just

With all due respect Jynx, if you must censor what I said I would prefer you just blank it out rather than alter it to say something I did not actually say.

In response to: Justice system is not just

Re: Justice system is not just

Hi @Jlol ,

I am sorry to hear that you're feeling harassed.

Jynx isn't on till this afternoon, I will let them know and raise your concerns with the SANE team.

11 - 19 of 19