I just want to be clear that I never abused my children, I hardly ever even raised my voice, and almost only in situations of danger. I'm sorry I have you the impression I have regrets over being abusive. I was not abusive. I have been accused of spoiling them by my mother and aunt, although I would not take their word on anything. Other friends and family thought I did a very good job and that they were a reflection of that. I do not understand why a close loving relationship with two of them disappeared at 16. Well, maybe I'm starting to, because I'm starting to wrap my head around how much influence the other parent can have on them and that being the bigger person, not responding in any way to their lies other than to reassure my kids and make sure they felt safe, thinking that my example was teaching my children the way to handle lies was the best response. Turns out I should have done something I just don't know what or if it would have helped. He has been paying me back since the day I left and it didn't matter how hard I tried to be a co-parent he just twisted everything. He stalked me, badmouthed me, called police on me for no reason and it's worth noting they were in agreement with that but they have to attend all reports even if the reporter is so drunk they can barely speak. He was so bad this son who has now left and gone to live with him blocked his number on my phone because he saw the messages he was sending.
I was raised in a deeply religious church and taught to carry guilt from birth. My mother left my father and children when I was 4 and we were taught she was a devil woman and that I was just like her. This doesn't mean I raised my children with abuse but it does cause me to go to guilt as a default mode when someone criticises me.
I'm sorry I'm so upset about this but even though I keep blaming myself and trying to find an answer, one that I can only look within for because there's no one else to ask, doesn't mean I was abusive. I can't ask my son because he's not here so I replay everything trying to decide if it was bad enough to cause him to leave, like he had a little job he often didn't do because he had a sore foot or elbow, so I'd do it for him. Then the next week he'd refuse to do it and I'd explain that it's right to give an employer notice and not just stop without letting them know and he'd get angry at me for explaining something like that to him. And I ask myself was I wrong to insist he give notice or was I wrong for doing the job for him when he wasn't getting up to it.