FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Our stories

9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

I'm fairly sure most of us have been there. That gut-wrenching, hot-under-the-collar feeling of hearing someone else's insensitive remarks about MI.

A lot of the time it can be our own friends and family trying to do right by us. Other times it can be people that simply just don't get it.

In this article, 9 Things not to say to someone with MI, the author, Tartakovsky, explains that many people don't know what to say because they've not learned how to respond to MI. She provides examples of nine common remarks people say and how to respond. Here's a few of them (go to link provided for full article):

“Get busy, and distract yourself.”

“With significant mental illness, [distractions] won’t work, not even temporarily,” Howes said. After a person slogs through various diversions, they’re still left with the same issues. “Ignoring the issue doesn’t make it go away.”

“Do you want to get better?”

For mental health blogger Therese Borchard, this was the most hurtful thing anyone has ever said to her. While she knows the person didn’t have ill intentions, it still had a powerful effect. “It implied that I was staying sick on purpose, and that I had no interest in pursuing health, not to mention that I was too lazy or disinterested to do what I needed to do to get better.”

“Change your attitude.”

While a change in perspective can be helpful, it doesn’t cure conditions such as ADHD, bipolar disorder, PTSD or schizophrenia, said Howes. And changing one’s attitude isn’t so easy either. “It’s incredibly difficult for a high-functioning person to change their attitude, let alone someone debilitated by an exhausting mental illness.”

What are your thoughts? Is it best to teach others what to say? Or are we fighting a tiring battle? What are some of the insensitive remarks you've heard and how did you respond? @SCORPION I thought of this topic after reading and commenting on your post. I'd love hear your thoughts on this. Any thoughts from our active contributers @Uggbootdiva @kenny66 @Loopy @kristin @Alessandra1992 @kato @PeppiPatty?

248 replies

221 - 230 of 248

In response to: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Hi @Zahara
I agree with what you wrote. I think that sometimes it would be so nice for someone to take over and look after me.
And yes hugs included!!
Also even having friends bring some food over when really bad would help. It's so different when there's a physical injury, friends rally around and help so much. But mental illness- nothing.

In response to: Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

@Sahara Ditto - I felt exactly the same way you did when I had a Breakdown. @BlueBay there was very little help for me also. It is hard to know what to say sometimes but yes, we do have to try. Hugs ❤️

In response to: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

People just can't handle it. With BPD it really pushes all my abandonment buttons, hurts so bad, beyond conttol, but, I've been surprised, here in the last half of my life, to learn the power of self compassion. Its actually quit a skill I'm learning to harness, to strengthen and the blows, they don't hurt so much. I found the secret weapon. Compassion - starting with me. Have you tried?

In response to: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Hi @Former-Member
Yeah I need to work on self compassion. I struggle so much with abandonment because of BPD.

In response to: Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Compassion for myself? If that means moving away from abuse etc, yes I have tried it. Looking after myself? most of the time. But it is the reality of living with the mental scars and heartache of the preset that no amount of compassion for myself will ease. Only hope and time will do that. Regardless if that's the wrong thing to say in my life it's been the truth.

I needed the love of others when I had a breakdown and now - I will admit it. Although very independent and strong willed I can't do this solely on my own. Can anyone? I think we need "the right people who are good for us at the right time in life , at those vital times or tragedy can strike. We need others - even if that is just one person, they can change someone's world.

In response to: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

sorry was really just venting but probably in the wrong place.

In response to: Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Hi @BlueBay - BPD is part of what my daughter suffers together with bi-polar. Abandonment being a big issue for her - she can't be alone without a partner for this reason and rushes in. What advice or practical help/support do you find helps you or hinders you with abandonment?

It is so good to be able to speak freely here and be myself without judgement I will say, to express myself, ourselves, honestly without a mask, to be heard equally - I find that supportive and healing.

As having suffered a mental breakdown I was called a whinger, weak, pathetic, loser, selfish, negative and crazy - all of which added insult to injury. Obviously said out of frustration and anger. Definitely not love at the time.

Also I was given advice out of love that I didn't want to hear at the time, that was painful - some of it stated here being the wrong thing to say to those with MI; but which turned out to be life saving advice for me in the long run! So it can be a two edged sword - what is the wrong thing to say to one may be right for another and impossible to to put in a box as one size fits all . We are all different and I felt that important to express in my humble opinion and experience.

And the beautify of this forum is we can "all" express this individuality honestly due to our own life experiences that we have found helped us. A positive thing. Hugs 🤗

In response to: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Hi @Former-Member
I struggle a lot with abandonment. My parents abandoned me 6 yrs ago when I told them of my childhood abuse. Then my siblings don't talk to me except for one. Then this year in sept my therapist of 5yrs told me he couldn't help me anymore. More abandonment. That was huge. I felt betrayed lost alone and couldn't cope. I have just starting seeing a new psychologist.
I think for me I jump in and do or say things without thinking of consequences until much later when my mind is rational. Is your daughter seeing someone professional for help for BPD? Have you heard of DBT (dialetical behaviour therapy) it is specific for BPD sufferers. Maybe look into that.
I'm hoping this new psychologist will help me. But first she said I have huge issues with abandonment and my mum.
I hope this helps. I'm happy to chat more about this with you.

In response to: Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Hi @BlueBay - it's a terrible thing when those who we thought we could trust and love don't believe us when we are open and honest about the pain we have harboured silently for so long. And then have a psychologist say they can no longer help us. Not good at all. I have had friends in the past tell me the latter with their therapist saying they could no longer help them. This was mainly due to them feeling they were getting no where, had failed or they didn't want to listen anymore.

But my belief is that if a patient is still going back to them years later the psychologist has not failed. They are keeping their client alive. Sometimes that is what it is about as some scars never completely heal. Some of us just need others to help us carry them better - to see us through. There doesn't have to be obvious improvement for successful counselling in all cases. That's in my opinion, what do you think? What do others expect from therapy - vast improvement or just someone who listens, empathises and supports with some practical advice to cope?

In response to: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Re: 9 things NOT to say to someone with MI - Teaching others what to say

Ditto @coffeegirl

i have a similar peeve about radio jocks and comedians adopting the word, "triggered" when referring to something that is about to be said that you might disagree with or make you mildly irritated.

Triggering is a serious matter and an extreme form of suffering for anxiety and PTSD sufferers (and possibly others? Pardon my ignorance ) it's no joke.

but what can you do but pretend to find it funny like everyone else or be called out as moralistic or worse - making mountains out of molehills....

221 - 230 of 248