FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Welcome and getting started

Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

I've been realizing something recently and it had come from the lifetime-ago utterances of the woman my ex-husband ran off with. Her prior, second husband's and her unit had been burgled and when asked if she thought it was because they were on the end of the unit row, she adamantly agreed. Exposed, vulnerable and unprotected like the other units which huddle in and are protected on all sides. That's how I feel–exposed, vulnerable and unprotected...and burgled.

My place in my birth family is tacked on the end too. Eight and ten years separate me from my older brothers. They are from a different world, a different time and I was, effectively, an only child. They went ahead of me and sullied the world I grew up in, and I had no option but to wade through the mess they had made with their youthful dalliances. My world was already tainted. It didn't need words or explanation. It just wasn't pleasant for a young girl.

So there I am, tacked on the end of my birth family, and it has been like that ever since. That is my dilemma. I'm always tacked on the end–the late comer–in groups of any kind; and I am always left feeling that they are a cohesive group but I just don't fit it anywhere. And just as in my youth, I feel as though the world I move in has already been shaped and I can't be me, I have to adjust to others' misshapen worlds. And I can't, so I just don't fit in.

The reason I'm thinking out loud here is that I was just looking online for 'I don't fit in' and there was a lot of advice to a lot of previous posters, none of which was relevant, and I don't think it would be helpful to anyone who feels as I do. So my question is: has my birth position wrecked everything for me for life? Is that my problem?

Others are only children and don't have this problem, but can it affect some of us all our lives? Can birth position affect us to this extent?

I have been feeling very low today and, as always, chewing the cud. There is such a pattern to my life and I have been unable to break into another slipstream. I'm feeling that I just can't go on much longer as no-one can live in isolation.

Today I've been going through some old e-mails that I exchanged with my oldest brother a year or so ago. It lasted for about two exchanges before it erupted. All those serious grievances that have been 'under the rug' began to resurface, as they should. Family have to be able to relate, discuss, remedy and reconcile, and we never did. We hadn't had contact for a couple of decades, and I really wanted to reach out and relate as we should always have done. He just doesn't respond to me–like I'm an alien he misunderstands at every point, and doesn't want to think otherwise of me. My other brother doesn't even respond that much. I'm broken-hearted over this. We only have each other and they don't want me. And I need them so much. I just want to be a family like we never have been. I just hurt and I would be surprised if they didn't too. So why can't we just keep seeking common ground and be a family? Why can't they see how important this is? My heart is breaking.

20 replies

11 - 20 of 20

In response to: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

I find the so-called 'mentally ill' so often the only place I can find people who are more than skin deep, who actually think intelligently, and feel, and consider others.

@Appleblossom, are you saying that your birth family was encumbered with shame, rejection, poverty and pain? I hadn't previously concluded that, but if so, so was mine. Broken people. It destroys self-respect and dignity, and the desire to belong to it. I tried to make something of myself, to not accept that being a 'loser' was my lot in life.

In my brother's e-mails of last year, he said that I 'lived in an ivory tower' and always thought myself better. Better than a broken loser in a family of broken losers? I am better, and so are they! I aspired to being better than a loser! And I went through hell to achieve it while my birth family went from bad to worse. I have achieved what I wanted to share with all of them and help them to achieve, but they don't want me. They are comfortable as losers. They are unchallenged, avoid responsibilities, and life hurts but it's better than trying to work through the mess of our family for them, apparently. Three sibs who don't speak to each other or to their own children. They've dropped down the social ladder and allowed our detractors to get away with our destruction. We relate like oil and water. And how I miss them all, and that innate sense of belonging. What can I say?

In response to: Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

@Historylover Yes to the shame poverty and neglect in my birth family. Significant homelessness when I was 6 culminating in both parents hospitalised and we 4 kids placed in state care. I can live with my choices. (edited to remove identifying personal info)

Regarding living in an ideal world. The world of books and music was a LOT better than the world outside my head. I am practical enough to be aware of that and attend to material matters. Sometimes it can be about social aspiration. I am in weird situation where the one "friend" I have from childhood was always richer than me/us (new clothes and furniture) but always rougher and less educated, and drunk and swore a lot. It was not my family's way. Maybe they swore in another language and I missed all that ...

Find your narrative and live out the rest of your life with dignity.

Recently I reflected on some of your earlier posts, and it is important for me not to be naieve and keep in my memory the limitations of most people. I thought History Lover is right ... about being careful of viper's nests. At first I thought it was a bit extreme, but I need to be adult enough not to be surprised and caught out by other's problems. The social world is a mess. We are what we are.

Good talking with you.

In response to: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

@Appleblossom, I can't find our recent conversation about my difficulty with my teachers, but I just wanted to update you on the results of my recent assessment. I got a distinction and a very pleasant comment. I think they are realizing that I'm not out of my depth and taking up their more valuable time. So, I'm feeling a lot more positive about it all now.

I hope all is well with you. I've started early on my Aboriginal Studies course and am finding it engrossing. My mind boggles about what they have had to endure. I don't know how they have been able to. Cheers @Appleblossom. Stay well.

In response to: Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Hi @Historylover

Congratulations on your distinction! That's awesome. I'm so glad you are feeling more positive about it now and feel validated by your teachers. I hope it continues for you.

I agree about Aboriginal people and what they have had to endure. In my uni courses I had to do a few units similar to this one you mention and I was proudest about my HD for those units. It was so important to me as a white person that I get my head around the issues they have faced. Good luck with the continuation of the course!

Hanami

In response to: Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Congratulations @Historylover Glad you have some recognition.

My path has crossed with many indigenous people over the years.

Its important their stories are told, and they are talented with story and yarning …

My day has gone up and down and up so far .. with 2 good conversations and a bit of a physical workout.

Keep being you. Everyone else is already taken.

In response to: Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Thanks @Appleblossom. Just thought I'd keep you updated on the outcome. I'm always aiming for the HD but D will do. It's not far off. I hope your day is soon more up than down. I'm currently fiddling with PowerPoint. Clever. Take care.

In response to: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Hey @chibam. I haven't seen you about. Are we good?

In response to: Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Very much so, @Historylover !😃 I hope I haven't given you cause to believe otherwise?

I tend to dip in and out of SANE, tbh. So I'm sorry if I've missed anything you've posted. I don't always have the oomph to be on here. Seems like it's just a sea of people trudging through dark days, reaching out for help; but I find I can rarely offer any. Just a repetition of their own woes (or similar), and a comparable confusion about how they can be fixed. 😕

In response to: Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

@chibam. I know what you mean re trudging through dark days. I've been deep in my own, and to be honest, just can't get out of them anymore, so I'm not good company. I hope you're doing alright. And I agree re not being able to know how to help, or what to say. We can't, can we? Most of the time, I leave it to those who feel they may have a better connection to the problem, otherwise I'm just saying the same thing over and over–and I can't help myself!

Anyway, I just wanted to check in with you. I've missed you about. You cannot imagine the delight I've had in our interactions over the past couple of years, in my most difficult times. You've brought a happy smile to my face on so many occasions, and out-loud, joyful laughter from my soul on others.

Anyway, just sending best wishes and hope all is well with you. Cheers.😊

In response to: Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

Re: Thinking out loud to my online 'family'.

@Historylover Congratulations on your distinction!

11 - 20 of 20