FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Events and updates

ABC Q&A: Continue the discussion

ABC Q&A: Continue the discussion

Hi everyone,

As some may know Sunday 4 Oct - Saturday 10 Oct is Mental Health Week. During this week, the ABC will be running programs on TV and radio that revolve around Mental Health.

On Monday night we saw the focus on mental health, with panelists:

  • Professor Ian Hickie, Brain and Mind Centre, University of Sydney
  • Wayne Schwass, Former AFL star & mental health advocate
  • Professor Pat Dudgeon, Australian Indigenous Psychologist’s Association
  • Fay Jackson, Deputy Commissioner, NSW Mental Health Commission
  • Dr Roderick McKay, Director, NSW Institute of Psychiatry.

In this thread we aim to have a discussion and even debate about the topics on Q&A. Please keep it respectful and remember - everyone has various experiences and opinions, none of which are wrong; just different. So keep it productive and respectful.

Also, please no personal attacks on each other or panelists.. you can disagree, but keep it all above board 🙂

Once the show has finished, lets continue the conversations.

What do you wish was asked that wasn't?

What panelist did you identify with or what points do you feel passionate about?

33 replies

11 - 20 of 33

In response to: ABC Q&A: Continue the discussion

Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

everyone says it is a community issue, but how many people in the community know you have a mental illness? and of those people how many treat you differently because of it, no one knows who i am in my community because i have isolated, and i have had friends walked away form me because of MI

In response to: Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

YAY Peer support! Love that Fay talked about the importance of peer support

In response to: Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Fantastic points being made by Wayne (?) now about things OTHER than medication which were helpful to him. And for pointing out that medication is very much trial and error, which is a frustrating process.

In response to: Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

I'm in adelaide.

I suspect I am behind you gys on the east coast....

Fay just told the story about the drive across the Hay plains. I laughed so hard.

In response to: Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

I am so tired of politicians saying that if you have a job somehow you will magically be better, and i am tired of politicians saying people with MI getting better will contribute to the GDP, it is like you health does not matter, it is about making money!!!!!!!

In response to: Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

I'd be interested to see the stats Faye was talking about regarding lifespans of people on medications and see what the controls were... A metric-funk-tonne of variables in place makes it tricky to get clear results.

In response to: Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

WOW! What a whirl wind of a discussion.

What did you think?

What was the biggest point you agreed with?

What question do you think was missed?

I would love for our community to continue the discussion!

In response to: Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

@Jacques sadly money and the GDP are some of the most effective measures for politicians - they end up being what people vote for..... I feel too that this was a very 'political' appeal to the general public who may not give a stuff about a stranger's health mental or physical. By bringing the societal benefit into focus eg 'when the mentally ill are functional contributing members of society then society benefits', then Joe McDoesn'tCare can see maybe that this is a needed service.

In response to: Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Such a huge subject and so little time!

I would have loved to have had more discussion around treatment options and research and development of effective interventions.

I find it alarming that 'big pharma' is pulling out of research into psych medication - when there is SO much need for research and improvement in this area. To me that's like Cancer research just stopping because the current suite of treatments is 'fairly effective for quite a few people'.

I think therapy and psychological treatments are HUGE, but pushing away medication is to separate mental illness from physical illness; it implies that acrtually you COULD just will yourself better. Again, you don't see that standard applied to cancer.

In response to: Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Re: ABC Q&A: **LIVE NOW**

Queensland time here, show has just started now.

11 - 20 of 33