FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Our stories

Is my psychologist right?...

Is my psychologist right?...

So I have a question that has been bothering me since my last appointment with a psychologist a few days ago. Basically I have been seeing them through the oncology psychology service offered at my local hospital, to you know... deal with the stress, anxiety and general drama that dealing with cancer brings. So I don't generally talk to them about all my other issues. I had used my 10 MHCP visits this year for that.

Anyway, the past 3 visits I got the very strong feeling they wanted me to stop using the service. At the start of every session they give you one of those mental health screening assessments to see how you've been feeling recently. Mine have generally been pretty bad since a not-so-good test result last December. Before my last visit they hinted quite strongly that my results weren't improving and were still very high scores so maybe this wasn't working for me. I said I felt it was because I found talking to them about it helpful and that yes I'm still having trouble dealing with the new realities of everything but I wanted to continue working on it because it was still causing bouts of deep depression that I couldn't control. That seemed to work the first time. Then the next session I was also told, when the subject came up again, that maybe I've had too many sessions. Finally in my last session a few days ago it was brought up again but this time a bit more... 'less-hinty'!

I told her that I had booked an appointment with the people I had spoken to 3 years ago when I got my adoption records as I had recontacted them and asked if their service could help me work through my attachment issues (which I had just discovered the concept of and thought it explained a lot and described me pretty accurately) and I was told that I should just see them then instead of continuing as I was. I said that I was going to this new service to work on my ongoing childhood issues and that I felt the cancer issues were separate. So I would like to work on them both independently, although admitting there is some crossover, but that ultimately this was a service through Relationships SA and so not suitable for helping me to deal with depression from serious health issues.

So she then told me that it makes her feel bad when I keep coming in to speak to her and she feels like she isn't helping me. Maybe it was because I didn't immediately drop to my knees and beg her forgiveness for making her feel bad but she then went on to say I was using this service as a crutch and that I would be better off being discharged, because I would then work on my issues relating to my cancer, rather than not dealing with it because I had the 'safety net' of coming to these appointments. I really had no answer to that and just felt like I didn't want to continue if every appointment was going to have more and more time devoted to me basically begging to continue. The service is free for cancer patients and so it's not easily replaced without paying to see someone else which isn't easy when you're not working. So i said I believed her that this might end up being beneficial for me to leave and left.

So now I have no professional support in regards to dealing with my diagnosis. I still have my support group which is great but not really helping me to accept my own battle and worries about the future. It's been really bothering me since that appointment finished and so I just wanted to get some other opinions. Was she right and it will be helpful for me to not see them anymore? Or were my ongoing string of bad test results bringing their averages down so they wanted to move me on? I sort of feel a bit abandoned and like I was just thrown in the too hard basket. Maybe is was just good advice and I need to try it... I really don't know.

Thanks for any thoughts you may have to share. Sorry about the long post but, well it's me, so that's just going to happen! 🙂

30 replies

21 - 30 of 30

In response to: Is my psychologist right?...

Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Thanks @tyme. The only free psych session I've had are the ones at the hospital and I got exactly what I paid for I guess. Even my 10 MHCP visits were a gap of $50 each. Well the first 6 were $32, but they put the price up for my last few. The only free support since have been the support groups. The only multidisciplinary I've been told about is my GP, oncologist and previously my urologist who occasionally communicate about me. So I've been told, I have no idea what happens or what they talk about.

I did work for a Neighbourhood centre for about 18 years, and got 'loaned' out to quite a few of the other local ones who were having IT issues. They did have lots of groups, but they were mainly craft and social groups, and mainly retire people. There was certainly nothing fancy like a gym or pool. Plus, most of the groups weren't free... there was usually at lease a small donation to pay for the room hire costs. Maybe it's just different here in Adelaide, I don't know what larger states have available... it sounds like a lot more than here. My partner has 'encouraged' me to join a local board game group. I still feel uncomfortable going but I do and I generally enjoy myself. Well, I enjoy winning anyway! 😁

Maybe I should take a look and see what's on offer at the centres these days. It can't hurt to look.

In response to: Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Re: Is my psychologist right?...

For me, I go through my local council. Through them, I then attend different groups, and further from that, I attend other groups... @MJG017

Another place that may have services was universities. Sometimes, the uni students in training run MH groups. I've done some on mindfulness, CBT and sleep program. They weren't FANTASTIC, but it was something I could learn bits and pieces here and there.

Also, are there agencies or people who can help you get subsidised or free admission for the Peer Work course? e.g. Centrelink affiliates? I'm not on Centrelink, so I don't know. But a lot of the courses can be subsidised depending on your income.

In response to: Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Re: Is my psychologist right?...

@tyme I used to have access to subsided study when I was on job seeker, but i'm not sure now that i'm on a DSP. Even then, they would only help with Cert 3 and under courses. Although my friend who is doing the Cert IV Mental health, I'm sure he said his job provider was paying for it. I meant to ask him, but the last two groups we go to, he's been sick or away so I haven't had a chance to talk to him about it yet.

I was hoping the woman form MHCSA I emailed, would have some info for me by now to follow up on, but still no word, so I may need to do some more investigating.

In response to: Is my psychologist right?...

Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Hi @MJG017

Hi again - it's Monday we have new episodes of Home and Away - Melbourne weather and I need a new washing machine - and life goes on - it's never dull - that's for sure.

That Facebook account was the group I found but I couldn't post the link - I will be interested in hearing how it goes - getting into your past about your feelings about adoption will not be easy but worthwhile - and give yourself time - we all need that.

I learned that there are times when no one in the adoption triangle is comfortable - the adoptee needs parents and everyone has the right to be displeased, the birthmother may not have wanted to relinquish the child - and the adoptive parents pick up the slack. But hey - had I not adopted my son I would not be here today communicating with you - and - you are so honest and open and about the same age as my son would be now. This - to me - is a good thing.

There are things about my son's life I don't share - there are the wonderful things this intelligent and challenged child said and did that I love talking about. His death is a reality - and I can talk about that - actually it's totally okay.

I hear what you are saying about your cancer. The treatments are not going well - and you are now waiting for what's next around the corner. I get it - that is not a fun way to live - it's realistic though.

Chronic pain is similar - I have had two failed surgeries and all sorts of medication and other interventions - now I say enough experimenting - give me the medication I am currently okay with and that's my choice. Actually - the first contraindication is patient refusal - this is the way I am going. I've had the pain for a long time - my shoulder was permanently damaged in a traffic incident a long time ago and at the ripe old age of 81 - that's it. So - that's time again. Always time it seems - it's never easy.

Choice is the word - we need to look at our choices - with cancer I really don't know enough - I do read more than I write in this forum - so I do know people battle with choices and time and other people - so yeah - it ain't easy being green either.

Go for any groups or professionals you can afford. Try them and see if they work - your openness and honesty in this forum is a plus - keep it up - it's a valuable trait.

Pleasing people - I guess we all try that - and until we are compromised in anyway it's okay to make friends - if it becomes toxic - it's time to get out. And what other people think of us is none of our business - just as what we think of them is none of their business. I learned a lot when I used to watch Dr Phil. Now I don't - watch Dr Phil

I will be looking forward to hear how things go with PASS - I don't answer your post as soon as I read it - I think it through - and I find this worthwhile - and I still wish you all the best

Owlunar

In response to: Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Hi @Owlunar2 It's been a bust few days and tomorrow is going to be another one so i;m trying to catch up on some stuff now while I can. I had a quick look through some posts on that adoption facebook group. Maybe it's just a very narrow slice by looking at the most recent posts but there does seem to be a bit a anger towards being forcibly adopted. That's not really my situation, but I do plan to make a post and see how it goes and try to find out more about that group.

I did remind me of an international forum I found when I first got my adoption records. I joined there and found it helpful for a while. But I found reading people telling about how close they had come to be with a newly found biological parent/sibling to be just too hard to read about. I found a post on this facebook group of a woman sharing a photo of here and a half sister and how they had become very close. It brought back all those memories from that forum a few years ago and I had to stop looking through the facebook page. I'm not sure that I'm ready to hear stories like that. It got like that 3 years ago, so i'm not sure if i'm ready yet. No one is happier for them than I am, but from a personal point of view I just find it too upsetting still.

Choices and time seem so interrelated. Choices on reflection seem good or bad after time has passed. Choices change over time. Like with medical treatments. Over time, they can start to become too much and our choices change. Not because we see things differently now, but we had to deal with effects of those treatment over time and it can become too much.

Thanks again for your reply. I really appreciate reading your perspective and support. I'm still looking forward to my PASS appointment tomorrow and i'm sure it will give me a lot to think about.

In response to: Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Hi @MJG017

I will be thinking of you tomorrow as you have your interview with PASS - I have no doubt this will be challenging for you - you must have questions and maybe you are not sure if you want the answers.

I guess you can ask the questions though - letting the people know you are not sure about the answers - it's something to think about - how far do you want to go? Personally - I have the need to know everything about what I am researching - other people want to be more selective - and it's a process - these things are always a process.

If you feel your adoption wasn't forced - or you know it wasn't - that's a good thing. My son's adoption was forced but I hadn't heard the term until I read your email - then I had to look it up on the internet of course - adoptive parents are left out on that website. This is okay for me - I already knew it. This was a new learning experience for me though - reading all that.

I did have a brief interaction with my son's birth mother through the Adoption Information Services which was satisfactory - I never went further though - so I guess this would be true - we only go as far as we feel okay about delicate situations

It's understandable that you are unsure about reading happy reconciliation stories. Do you really want that or not? That is the question - I don't need to know the answer - maybe you don't know it yourself at this stage. But you are searching for something - so asking questions is okay. Take your time - keep yourself feeling easy about it.

About these decisions and your medical decisions - I will quote you a line of poetry I love - from T S Eliot

In a minute there is time for decisions and revisions that a minute will reverse

There is always time to change your mind - but I wish you the best as you go forward - and success too

All the best

Owlunar

In response to: Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Thanks @Owlunar2

I think i'm ready to ask anything and everything. I really just want to find out as much about why I am the way I am, and why I've struggled so much to make connections with anyone in my life. I really did struggle so badly with this for so long. It was only about 14 years ago that I started to try to change things. It always just seemed pointless even trying before that. Looking back I think I was in a far worse mental place that I ever thought at the time. I always just thought I was a bit shy and lonely and, when alone, a bit sad.

But now, I think it was a lot more serious and I just lived with it like that until I started to see real problems as turning 40 rapidly approached. I guess those are some of the things i'm looking for answers for and what I can do to continue to improve. I just don't know how easy it will be to talk about that. It's all that really deep, deep personal stuff that you keep buried in the darkest recesses of your mind and never talk about. The thought of losing control emotionally worries me. I've talked to people before... mentioning little bits about this, and I could feel myself starting to lose control then. Maybe its a guy thing? I know I have to open a few doors in my head that have never been opened before and that's scary.

That's a very good question about my adoption being forced or not. I hadn't thought about that until I read it in your reply. I know mum was unmarried at the time of our births. It got me thinking about what my bio sister told me about mum. I think she did want to keep me, but a lot of pressure was put on her to give me up. I remember my sister telling me stories about herself as a baby being hidden in a drawer when people came around. Mum was so scared of losing her because someone would take her away. I came along 18 months later and I guess she couldn't hide it this time... the people around her had learnt from my sister.

I'd never thought about it like that until now. It makes me feel even closer to mum I think.. and even sadder for not getting to know her earlier. It's like we were both equally wronged. I am so happy though that I did get the chance to speak to her and that she knew I held no hard feelings toward her at all and was just happy to finally meet her. But yes, I guess I was a forced adoption as well, if my assumption about it's meaning is correct. Maybe I should pay a little more attention to that facebook group. Almost 54 years in and I'm still learning so much about this. I'm sort of glad that I didn't really know of this forced adoption before. Had I known that growing up, I think it would have been so much worse mentally. But maybe it would have been better... the fear of risking being rejected by my mother again by finding her would be greatly reduced and without that fear I would have tried to find her much, much earlier. Wow... it's a lot to think about. I'd probably sit here all night writing thoughts about it as they swirl through my head, so i'll stop now.

I was happy to read stories about people having very successful reunions, it was emotional, but in a happy way and it gave me hope that it was a possibility. But as time went on and I started to have doubts about my own biological family, it got harder and harder to read about. First it was my biological brother who stopped replying to calls and messages after we met in person for the first time. My two sisters told me he had always been like that, even with them so I begrudgingly accepted it.

Then after mum died, my sister stopped contacting me. My other sister (the eldest out of all of us and also adopted out) I still hear from every now and then. She's commented on my recent facebook posts about the media stuff I've been doing in relation to the fundraiser and even donated to it. I think it's just that i've formed the exact same relationship with them that I have with all my other family... even my partner's family. One where we all get on, when we do meet up, we sit together and we will talk and have fun, but if I don't keep contacting them, I never hear from them. I'm never invited to anything and I certainly don't calls asking about how i'm going with my health. So I can only do that for so long before I just get the feeling I'm the only one trying, and eventually give up.

I guess I will have more of an idea tomorrow about 11am when my appointment is over. That TS Eliot line does remind me of me a lot though. I may be reading it out of context, but to me it reminds me of all the times in my life I made a decision to change something about myself, or do something I wouldn't normally do only to change my mind... always due to lack of confidence/self esteem... and end up never changing anything. If there was ever anything that summed up my first 40 years, it is that.

Thanks once again @Owlunar2. I feel like you have me about as prepared for tomorrow as I'm ever going to be.

In response to: Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Re: Is my psychologist right?...

All the best for tomorrow @MJG017

Owlunar

In response to: Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Re: Is my psychologist right?...

@Owlunar2 I just back home from my appointment and it went really well. We talked about forced adoption and she is sending me information on all the latest information surround that closed adoption period of the 40s to 80s. It sounds like it was much worse that I thought with so much pressure put on women (especially those that were unmarried like mine) to pressure and force them to give up their babies. The federal government apparently apologised for it a few years back and some state governments have introduced, or are looking to) redress schemes for mother and adoptees. It as quite shocking and it will be interesting to read mor when she sends me that info.

They also have a couple of support groups for adoptees which was great news. Unfortunately the night one is every first thursday of the month which conflicts with my mens group but they also have a day group which I can attend, so she sending me the info on that as well. We also talked about a few other things with peer support which was great and I came out feeling like I, and my mother, are more victims that anything that was ever wrong with me. Which is a big change in my outlook and I think will really help me going forward. After so long, i'm still getting used to it all. I'm still getting used to the whole idea that my mother very likely never wanted to give me up in the first place. An idea that only entered my thoughts last night after reading your post. So I have a lot to think about and process and a lot to go forward with.

Thanks for sharing your experiences and your support. I hope your day has been as good as mine. Take care Owlunar2.

In response to: Re: Is my psychologist right?...

Re: Is my psychologist right?...

That is so good to hear @MJG017 - it must be wonderful to learn you and your mum are victims of a cruel system that has wrecked so many lives and that you have realised that she didn't give you up willingly I read about that today too and also have good news

I went back to the Forced Adoption website and found a phone number for anyone who was affected by a Forced Adoption and I as I am an adoptive mother I am entitled to 6-8 sessions with a counsellor.

This is an incredible coincidence. You had not thought your mother wanted to keep you until yesterday and I had not known about the term Forced Adoption until yesterday and also - I hadn't known the adoptive mother/father could be entitled to help.

I am so glad you had a good day - and now - all of us know more - we are innocent victims of a terrible crime and we can all work on that.

Yes - it was a good day - I never knew about those changes in adoption issues until I read the website more carefully. I Would not have realised this had you not brought it up

You and I can both move forward now - and I am sure you will find this more helpful to your life experience. I know I will.

Your mother can't though - but then - we have no knowledge of what people know of their loved ones - I am so pleased for you especially

You are 54 - my son would be 54 now too

Excellent

Owlunar

21 - 30 of 30