FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Managing thoughts of suicide & self-harm

People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Content/trigger warning

So I just watched this brief news/currant affairs segment about a mental health patient who recently committed suicide. And after all these years, the emphasis is still on the suicide, and not on the patient's suffering.

The segment was all about how her family had to go through all the death rigmarol, like ID-ing the body, and I'm not trying to deny the hardship that they go through in the wake of a suicide. But after all this time, people still don't really care about the suicidal person's suffering.

The "problem" that everybody's complaining about is that the suicidal person is dead.

The "lessons to be learned" that they were hinting at were all about creating more restrictive practices that are all geared towards making it more difficult for a suicidal person to end their life; not about doing a better job of making that person's life worth prolonging.

Nobody genuinely cares about how unspeakably agonizing a suicidal person's life is. The only thing anyone cares about is how to constrain them so securely that they can't possibly die, no matter how much they might want to. So long as the patient is alive, everything else is acceptable.

Nobody is really on our side, no matter how much they might insist otherwise. This is what it is to be truly alone.

I can't say much more because this forum is very skittish regarding the morality of suicide and suicide prevention. I've probably said too much as it is.

But if anyone of any influence does happen to see this - try, just for a little while, to considder that maybe, just maybe, the anguish of suicidal people might matter just a little more then your obsession with keeping them alive.

23 replies

11 - 20 of 23

In response to: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

So true, @Eve7 . Too damned true.

And it's been that way for too damned long, too.

In response to: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Folks here don’t even know @chibam they are sick of us. Heck I’m sick of me. Burden

In response to: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Just an fyi, not that it really makes any difference, but the media have very strict guidelines on how they report/ if at anything, about suicide. I have a friend who use to be high up editor for the daily telegraph. He wrote a story that made front page that involved something that I did many years ago, he couldn’t report on anything that I actually did, just how it affects the community. Sorry to be vague, need to remain anonymous.
Anyways, just to say they have strict guidelines on what they can say.

locally we had a mh case that closed streets for days. It was huge in the area, but not a peep in the media.

I guess it’s just so taboo, yet it affects so many people. Too sensitive. I don’t know.

if assisted dying for mh was ever approved here…..??

In response to: Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)


@Bow wrote:

Just an fyi, not that it really makes any difference, but the media have very strict guidelines on how they report/ if at anything, about suicide. I have a friend who use to be high up editor for the daily telegraph. He wrote a story that made front page that involved something that I did many years ago, he couldn’t report on anything that I actually did, just how it affects the community. Sorry to be vague, need to remain anonymous.
Anyways, just to say they have strict guidelines on what they can say.


Yeah, I know; the "MindFrame" guidelines. There was a fair bit of discussion about it on here a couple months or so ago.

IMHO, they're just confusing the hell out of the media, because they seem to have shut down parts of the media coverage that their ostensibly not designed to shut down; while the "problematic" aspects of suicide reporting seem to be occurring more then ever.

Not to mention the fact that they leave TV channels doing absurd things, such as editing out that scene in The Naked Gun where Ricardo Montalban's secretary pantomimes attempting suicide. Spoils the movie for everybody, and makes out that the suicidal community are so delicate, they can't even handle seeing a brief, and really tame allusion to suicide.


@Bow wrote:

locally we had a mh case that closed streets for days. It was huge in the area, but not a peep in the media.

I guess it’s just so taboo, yet it affects so many people. Too sensitive. I don’t know.


I believe that. I followed the Royal Inquiry into the Robodebt fiasco really closely, and many of the submissions to it detailed suicide attempts that were way more sensational then anything we ever heard about in the media. I was amazed that some of these stories never went mainstream public, because they were just so public and sensational. Or other stories about Centerlink customer service opperators who were entangled with multiple customers attempting suicide.

It went way beyond the two successful suicides we heard about in the media. Suicide was all over that scheme, yet it was barely ever reported. I couldn't believe the true scope of it, when I started reading some of those inquiry submissions.

We are certainly living under a very suppressed media, when it comes to the matter of suicide. I'm not denying that there are certain details and language about suicide that ought to be avoided where possible. But what we are living under goes way beyond that sort of dilligent, minimal editing. The suppression has become very counterproductive.

In response to: Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

I'm glad this discussion exists.

TW:

Content/trigger warning
I attempted suicide last night. Only to be yelled at and turned away from the hospital.

When you arr chronically suicidal people just turn you away thinking that you just want the attention. I am in pain. I'm tied. I am safe enough af the moment. But I feel compelled to state that. Even though I'm safe I don't feel safe. Like I'm not going to act again right now and feel like I have to tell everyone that so they dont get worried or concerned or triggered.

No seems to check in further than that. Yes I'm safe. But I don't want to be. I don't want to trigger anyone. But that's just what everyone is more concerned with than actually helping me.

In response to: Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

I think you have really nailed it @The-red-centaur in terms of the fact that there seems to be more concern with just keeping people alive than there is with putting effort towards helping folks to create a life worth living. And I am so sorry that you were turned away, how utterly demoralising. Let us know if there's anything we can do to support you at the moment hun 💜

In response to: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

we need all people to open up their hearts & minds to this.

Suicide.

It f*kn hurts each & everyday, just to be!

You've tried all the stuff, all the veggies & sun walks.

Why does this thing reach up from heart & just pull me down into black!

The courage it takes to end your life is massive. Tried twice myself.

Agree totally with you.

And we are not burdens. We are unwell.

This Christian aversion to Suicide is not evolved thinking.

We just want to talk about it!!!!

In response to: Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Red centaur.

I am happy to talk about suicide in real terms.

Not to deny. Not to dissuade. Just glanced off an attempt this Saturday gone.

Got too lazy & stoned to do it!!!

In response to: Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Hey @Malstupid just a lil tip, if you want other members to be notified that you've responded, you can tag them - use the @ symbol and a drop down will appear, and you can choose their name. If their name isn't there, you can type it out and it should then appear for you to select, and it will show up in blue, like this: @The-red-centaur

I am sorry to hear that you're struggling with suicide too at the moment. I am glad you've found our forums to come and find some kindred spirits, folks who understand what you're going through. It is heavy to sit with constant SI, I have also been there too. Definitely want you to be able to chat about it more - and I thought it may be helpful for you to have a read through our Guide to creating safety when talking about suicide online too.

Here for you, if there's anything you wanna chat about 💜

In response to: Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

Re: People Still Don't Sincerely Care About The Plight Of The Suicidal (TW: Suicide)

@Malstupid it does hurt.

I went to the beach to watch the sunset tonight. It was pretty. But I juts felt numb.

Now we got to drive 45min home.

It doesn't feel worth the effort to do what you're supposed to do. Living is hard. Doing the strategies constantly doesn't feel worth it anymore. I'm so tired.

11 - 20 of 23