FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Friends, families and carers

Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

TW: child abuse

Hi guys.

I know this is a pretty uncomfortable discussion to have here, but how liable are people with schizoaffective disorder for their actions, and how much should they be made to face the things that they have done?

When I was growing up, my schizophrenic mother had frequent episodes, and even as they became physical the line that was always used was "she can't help it". And I took that on board at the time, but now I wonder if that's entirely accurate, as it always felt like whenever she did something wrong she never had to apologise for what she had done, even if it was during a moment lacking clarity. Her behaviour would become more and more childish as I got older too.

Fast forward to a fair few years later, my wife has a schizoeffective father. Her upbringing with him was objectively worse, as he would be more physical and neglectful during her upbringing, and more crucially during her very young years (my mother got worse when I was into my tweens, so I at least had some decent periods of normality before that). She is extremely resentful of the things that he did during her young childhood, including things like forcing her to go out for dinner and not allowing her to change her soiled clothes (she had wet herself at school), shoving her downstairs for walking too slowly on multiple occasions, and one incident where he made a sibling leave home permanently before they were 16. And when I say made them leave home, I mean he actively told them not to be home when they got back, and mother had to find her a new place to stay.

As someone who grew up with a schizophrenic mother, I know how hard it effects one's life and how even in my 30s I'm still feeling its effects downstream. But I think in comparison I dealt okay with those trials when I put it against how my wife has dealt with it. She was never able to fully compartmentalise the things that were done to her. And it really made me think very hard about how much one who is mentally ill is responsible for their actions, particularly in the case of schizoeffective people.

The problem I'm really having with this time is he just spent a couple of months in and out of hospital for medication changes, during which he said some utterly reprehensible things about everyone in the family. And the thing that is really bothering me is now, much like he always has handled things, he's trying to act like the things didn't happen, and whenever they're brought up he just acts suprised and says he didn't know he did that. Not even followed up with a sorry, sometimes accompanied with a sheepish grin. And while I can sorta separate the disorder from the person, even I'm infuriated by this behaviour as it feels like he would prefer pretend things haven't happened than face them and apologise.

All I'm asking is for him to take some responsibility for his actions. Is this unreasonable? Am I being unfair? Should people with schizoaffective disorder be made to acknowledge their actions during episodes?

I'm sorry if this feels rude or nasty. I've been living with this literally my whole life and how much it deeply affects my wife really gets to me. I kinda want her to be able to get over it and live life but also understand why she wants it to stop. Even now in our 30s he still talks to her like a lazy teenager.

Thanks for you time.

15 replies

11 - 15 of 15

In response to: Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

Re: Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

@Adelle I'm sorry to hear it. I'll be honest after living with it pretty much permanently for nearly 40 years I do have moments where I find it hard to be empathetic about it. But I really hope that being in custody might help him get back on the right track. Unlike his brother I'm embarrased or ashamed of my father in law, or my mother. But the anger is pretty real, and I feel a little like the world has done both of them a disservice by treating them like people who "can't help it". They can't help it in the moment, that's very real. But I think the reason I'm wanting an apology for some of the crap I've been put through over the last couple of months is that I firmly believe that my father in law has been treated as if there is no consequence for his actions over the years, and so whenever he has had an episode he got the opportunity to just pretend it didn't happen. Which I understand, and relate to. He acts like a cheeky child when confronted with stuff he's done though, and I think that's because of the lack of consequence over the years. Ugh. Sorry, I'm just ranting at 3am instead of going to bed. But I hope the point of what I'm struggling with here is at least seen?

Once again, I hope that your son gets some help that he's able to accept. Take care.

In response to: Re: Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

Re: Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

Hi there, yes it has been many years for us as well.. 35 in fact, and it became worse about 11 years ago after a change in medication, then gradually noncompliance.

I believe being in custody for what is likely to be a minimum of 2 years has taught him finally to accept being on medication, but who knows.

It has stabilised him at least.

I agree that many people who suffer from mental illness don't have a level of insight and self care and are somewhat like a recalcitrant child when everything falls apart.

I have "picked up the pieces" so many times, it is tiring, but I am a parent, I love him and will continue to do so.

My biggest focus is to keep my own mental and physical health in order so as to be a support

Good luck..

In response to: Re: Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

Re: Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

@RublesTime, there’s this symptom of schizophrenia where it’s like ‘I’m not sick! I don’t need to keep taking my pills!’, I think it’s called anosognosia? Maybe that could also be a factor?

In response to: Re: Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

Re: Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

@Gwynn in the case of FoL, I don't think so. Even when he's been taking his medication properly, he just refuses to acknowledge his involvement in negative things. For example:

"Oh! Why doesn't she like me? I thought I was a good father."
"As a child you would shove her down the stairs because you were too impatient to wait, and never apologised. When she would complain, you would scold her for talking back."
"Did I? I don't remember that."

"Even if you don't remember it, it happened."
"But I was a good father." *walks away*

another good example was when we were playing him back the voicemails of the things he had said about us, accusing us from everything from infidelity to changing his bank account details, he just looked at the phone and stared at us blankly. "I don't remember doing that." *walks away*

He will go and do something else in these situations, not walk off to be alone and be upset. I should point out, he *is* capable of being quite visibly sad about things. I've been him weep openly listening to sad music, he's cried watching sad television. But if he does something wrong, he won't admit fault, and even giggle like a kid when he's caught doing something wrong. Mum was similar, I remember once when she ruined our dinner at a restaurant (literally had a sudden flurry of anger and upended the table's food) she was giggling and not acknowledging what happened. Like a kid who'd been caught out.

In response to: Re: Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

Re: Schizophrenia and responsibilties for action TW

@RublesTime It is such a difficult and selfish disease.. like alcoholism in many ways.. Blame the disease aka "it wasn't my fault"

In my situation, My son will more than likely comply with medication and lead a full life when he is released. The experience of his last episode and being in jail has been his rock bottom (I say this with fingers crossed of course)

I used a counsellor through ARAFMI (you get 5 free sessions). I wasn't sure about this, but I did have 3 sessions and found it helped me.

I had alcoholic parents// wicked uncles who did the wrong thing by me as a child// a violent manipulative alcoholic husband, and then the mental illness of my son.. ALL these situations are pure madness, but I learned I could never change them, just change the way I respond rather than react.

Reach out and chat/ vent whenever you feel like it.

11 - 15 of 15