FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Our stories

Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

I was chatting to a very very good friend who owns her own business. She and I have been through heaps together and understand each other's mental state very well.

She was discussing a staff member that hadn't been working out, so they had "managed her out of the job" ie. encouraged and assisted her to get employment somewhere else. And then she added " and I was starting to we signs of mental illness as well" I laughed and said " well yes I am sure you can pick that up these days"

But now I have had time to think about it, it is pretty bad. She has employed someone else who turned out to be bipolar and he couldn't do his job as he was very depressed. I am bipolar so she came to me at the time to talk about it. They are a small business and can't afford to keep someone on who can't perform. She herself has and does suffer depression and panic attcks so she empathised with the guy but they couldn't afford for him to stay. He knew that and left of his own accord.

The thing is both of us have been able to push through and keep our jobs when we have been very sick, only because we have money and can take sick leave or get hospitalised and we both have enormous family support. So we are both awesome at keeping it hidden professionally.

It wasn't the reason they let the girl go (euphemism!) but she mentioned it at the end.
I can't stop thinking about it, we all talk about remove the stigma, and legally you can't discriminate against those with a medical condition, but mental illness is risky. You don't know when it might happen. It's not like being in a wheel chair - they can still do their jobs, it's not like breaking your Arm - that has a finite time frame for getting better. I thought if we the mentally ill won't even employ people with illness then how on earth can we expect others to?
No resolution, but in light of all the mental health stuff, and remove the stigma etc. it just left me feeling flat and hollow.

17 replies

11 - 17 of 17

In response to: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

Re: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

@ivana small business - less than 30 employees.
The employee let go -let's just say fired - was in a junior role.
industry - professional (accounting or law for example.)

she was assisted to get a new job went straight from one to the next.

In response to: Re: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

Re: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

If her situation was 5 employees then perhaps it would be more understandable.
How were they able to get another employer to hire her if her productivity was so low?

In response to: Re: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

Re: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

15 is still a small business.
She was helped into a role with a different type of client that matched her skill set. My friend did not have that kind of client in her business.

In response to: Re: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

Re: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

Do you know how she feels about it? (The girl who was managed out)

In response to: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

Re: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

of course not. I have nothing to do with it. I have never met the girl I imagine she would either be really pissed off or pleased with her new job.

In response to: Re: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

Re: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

I am in the position of being managed out right now. For almost a year I have been on indefinite leave from my job as a middle manager with a professional association because of major depression and anxiety.

Since late January, I have been paid income insurance to cover 75% of my former salary. (So things could have been a lot worse, to be honest.) In four weeks, that income insurance will come to an end because my clinicians (GP, psycologist, psychiatrist) advised the insurers via the OT contractor that I am fully fit to work anywhere ... except my former job.

I knew that my former workplace was not a good situation for me to be in. But I still had to go through the process, in good faith. To suggest to my employers things that would help me in my return, which I did in a meeting a month ago. I thought it'd help them too because I can see them being in the same position with the next person who sits in that chair on a permanent basis. But the replies came back from across the table 'No, we disagree.' Ad infinitum.

Before that meeting, I thought a lot about the suggestions I would make. I knew as I prepared for that meeting that the suggestions that I made were the sort of things that wouldn't endear me to my boss or the CEO because what I said implied that their way of doing things was ... just maybe ... less than 100% ideal and a culture was being instilled where people in some positions were expendable and others could do what they liked. It was a calculated risk, and I didn't expec things to change. But I approached that meeting constructively and in good faith. And I'm being repaid for it by having my income insurance stopped.

Yesterday, my boss emailed me asking for a follow-up meeting to discuss the prospects for my return. Assuming that their attitude hasn't changed, I'd have a relapse if I were to return. I don't want to be in that position again.

The aren't a lot of permament jobs about in my profession. I'm getting some freelance work starting next week at a former employer. But I'd rather have a permanent job. It doesn't need to be a massive earner. It doesn't even need to match the salary I used to make. (You don't go into my profession expecting to become rich.) But the applications I've been putting in all year have got me nowhere.

In response to: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

Re: Being managed out or let go for mental illnesses

@Zinoviev that totally sux I am so sorry.
Was it the job that caused you to have the problems? It sounds very stressful? In that case they do have a duty of care to you. Of course that can mean jack shit out in the real world. In any case not being paid would exacerbate anything that is happening for you right now. I think you were incredibly brave and resilient to try and change the conditions even though it didn't work.
I have no answers. everything suddenly gets so complicated When money is involved. integrity and what should be the right thing to do ...
11 - 17 of 17