FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Something’s not right

Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

This is a very common concern in therapy, but I thought I would get your thoughts.

How do you balance being honest enough with your therapist that they will be able to help you in a meaningful way and being vague enough that they don't take you to hospital even though you don't need to or don't want to?

That is a horrible sentence, but I hope you get the idea. How bad does it have to be to warrant involuntary admission?

31 replies

21 - 30 of 31

In response to: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Me too.

In response to: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Hi @Former-Member

This is a real tricky subject and very much a common concern I think amongst people that see a psychologist/psychiatrist.

I try and be as open and honest with my support team. There has been a few times where my pdoc has admitted me, and looking back, he probably made the right decision.

Then again, there have been a few times where I have not been as open as I could have with my support team. It is a real struggle at times and I think it comes down to how much you trust them.

I hope this helps and makes sense too.

Snowie xoxo

In response to: Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

@Snowie

@Netty78

@Bunniekins

@chibam

@Gwynn

@Bow

@Eden1919

@SJT63

@TideisTurning

@Appleblossom

@AussieRecharger

Thank you so much for your support, guys. I wanted to quickly share with you a document talking about the process for suicide risk assessment in the public health system in NSW. This is ABSOLUTELY only intended as a guide, and I'm sure the organisations that your therapist is a part of will have their own guidelines, but it is a very interesting read. OBVIOUSLY REALLY [...] TRIGGERING FOR SUICIDE.

Reading it gave me the confidence to say that I probably won't be hospitalised if I'm honest about my thoughts, and I can be more comfortable than I was before I read it. Wish me luck!

In response to: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Hi @Former-Member ,

what a great question. In my view just shut up unless you want to be hospitalised or just given loads of phone numbers to call. People shut down and want to pass the problem on so they don’t feel responsible

peri

In response to: Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

I avoid the topic of suicidal thoughts with health care professionals (or anyone really), it scares peoole. I've find a Safety Plan & a Coping Box helpful, where you CONTRACT YOURSELF to take steps before acting.

This is what therapists or friends should help you with, and also help you build that life worth living! - without throwing the baby out with the bathwater. I really hope more Counsellors read this thread. To Know how we feel
___
I found this discussion thread tonight in looking for somewhere to plop my own struggle with thoughts of suicide tonght. Actually it's been building up for fee weeks now (not surprising being this time of year), and my sleep patterns & relationships are suffering. Today I had the very powerful thought: "Why don't you do it now so those accountable for managing final affairs / goodbyes (funeral, cremation, WILL)... so they dont have the inconvenience of taking time off work, so they can get it all out the way before they have to go back to work in the new year"


Does anyone else have these type of thoughts? A lot of "JUST DO IT!" scenarios have popped into my head lately. It takes me by surprise so I don't think it's my thoughts. It's gotta be another entity. Hard part is knowing what I want. Immediately my stress levels spike concerned if i'll be able to resist 😖vim so tired

Please Don't panic, I'M SAFE, but I sure could do with a listening ear.

Maybe SI is an alarm bell (like a toothache) that's telling me that 'All is not well & to take stock and reduce stressors somehow' I donno, what Sonu think? . I have past trauma that comes back to haunt me this time of year, it's hard to stop that, and Exhausting to connect heart to thought to heart (be aware), near impossible really.
I've taken something to try sleep tonight (2am), often a fresh start breaks it.

Any advice @Former-Member ? bit lost at the moment

In response to: Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Hi @Rosemary4

Just popping by to offer some support & after reading through your post, I really find what you described as a useful strategy - that way of contracting with yourself, interesting. I came across a small pocket book that someone with a lived experience of suicidality had created which had a similar idea behind it.
Can’t quite think of the name of it right now though unfortunately.


I’ll try dig it up & see if I can find it to post if I do.

I hope you don’t mind me sharing some other resources?

I was just wondering if you have heard of or tried the Alternatives to Suicide peer groups or Alternative to Emergency Department drop in services that run?

  • The peer support groups offer a regular group time to talk about experiences of suicide with people who have that lived experience themselves.

  • The drop in services are a physical space that people with experiences of distress & thoughts of suicide can seek support in instead of going to the emergency department. The service is staffed with people who have had their own lived experience of SI & can provide peer support. (Often called Safe Haven)

I’ve noticed more popping up in various places over the year & just thought I’d share that as a resource, in case it might be of interest to you.

I’ve also heard others describe what you mentioned about maybe SI & being like an alarm. For what it’s worth, makes a lot of sense to me.

Take care

In response to: Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Thanks @Former-Member, No, I haven't heard of "Alternatives to Suicide peer groups" or "Alternative to Emergency dpt drop in"
Wonder who to ask in Brisbane to find them.
Just have to ride it out, ignore these thoughts. Hope they're not "VOICES" 😟 (psychosis), they're inside my head. They're not BELIEFS, though they are linked to feelings .. which brings me back to circumstances, and stress levels. Have to own and better manage my stress. Where do we get the energy to discipline when we're so flat 😟 Wish I lived in a small supportive little village. Yep, bit of a dreamer here.





In response to: Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Bit sad 🎄

In response to: Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

I really respect how you view your experience @Rosemary4 & what you make of it.
You mention managing stress, just wondering what are the ways you personally find helpful in managing stress?

And about the ALT to Suicide services - Yeah, I have often thought about sharing them here in the forums as I think many people might find them a helpful option.

I am not 100% over ones in Brissie, but there are some links to the groups here which are online so you can dial in australia wide - depending on time zone etc.

https://alt2su-nsw.net/support-groups/

The drop in centre services are funded to roll out across Australia & often called Safe Haven but not always.

There was one I knew of called Living EDge at Redland Hospital but not too across current services.

You could possibly do a search or contact your local MH centre to ask, as they might know more.

Strong image of the eye, tear & chritsmas tree - not always a happy time of year....

In response to: Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Re: Being too honest about suicidal thoughts?

Thanks again @Former-Member,
Managing Stress 🤔 hmm:

Gett off the couch more
Walk the block EVERY day
Eat vegies every day
Tidy environment
Ring someone 4 a chat
Deep breaths, centre self
Meditate/pray accept grace
Like myself (x5 good traits)
Forgive offensive ppl
Don't hide away
...
yep, I'll just start with the dishes 😕 No, maybe eat, haven't even had brekky yet...

21 - 30 of 31