FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Something’s not right

Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Hi everyone

I was wondering if anyone new what was the difference between bipolar 1 and schizophrenia. I know with bipolar 1 you have hallucinations, delusions etc plus a mood disorder like depression. With schizophrenia (particularly schizoaffective disorder) you have the same ..... so what is the clincial definition in layman's language.

Just curious as I was first diagnosed with bipolar 1 then schizoaffective disorder. Son2 also has schizophrenia but has huge manic swings. It seems there is a fine line drawn between the two diagnosis. Thanking in advance. peax

14 replies

1 - 10 of 14

In response to: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

@Bunniekins here are are some visuals that may help

In response to: Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

@Former-Member thanks Darcy just waiting for the pics to show. I like visuals as they often explain so much better than paragraphs of writing.

In response to: Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

@Former-Member Hey Darcy the diagms are great but it still doesnt explain the difference between bipolar I and schizo affective disorder. As they both have hallucinations and delusions and mood disorders...... I am a confused pea 😮

In response to: Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

@Bunniekins is this easier?

In response to: Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

@Former-Member Yes that has helped alot :)x

In response to: Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

I have wandered and wondered through masses of literature on the subject. @Bunniekins

I have diagnoses of all of them in my family and changing ones .... etc .. mostly it seems there are a few spectrums and I concentrate on the person in front of me ... labels are just a guideline ...

Hugs Gp

You've morphed into a doc!

In response to: Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Appleblossom Just googled and got this

Schizoaffective Disorder is often confused with Bipolar Disorder with psychotic features. Both diagnosis include mood changes that impact life as well as symptoms of psychosis. ... However, when mood problems flare up, such as during a depressed or manic episode, the symptoms of psychosis can worsen.

In response to: Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Hi @Gazza75 thanks for your support. Have you got any ideas on when the diagnosis flips from one to the other? I have a feeling I will have to ask my psychiatrist next time I see her.

In response to: Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Hi @Bunniekins, I am sorry I don't. I have Bipolar 2. Definitely worth talking to your doctor. Wishing you well.

In response to: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

Re: Bipolar 1 vs schizophrenia

@Bunniekins the way i understand it is that with Bipolar 1 you shouldnt have psychotic symptoms unless you are in a mood episode and that the psychosis is a result of the mood but that the psychosis only comes when you are manic or depressed or mixed but NOT when your mood is stable.

Shcizoaffective is when you have mood symptoms found in Bipolar but you experience psychosis OUTSIDE of a mood episode ASWELL as when you are in a mood episode.

and Schizophrenia is when you have psychosis for a period of time longer than 6 months consistently and you can have mood symptoms in schizophrenia but the mood is driven by the psychosis where as it is the other way around in Bipolar. so Schizophrenia means the mood is caused by psychosis and Bipolar 1 with psychotic features is the psychosis is caused by the mood.

it also has to do with the length of time you experience different symptoms. I hope this made sense if i could draw a huge chart i would but anyway hopefully that helps.

1 - 10 of 14